Pool Equipment Brand Comparison: Pentair vs. Hayward vs. Jandy

The three giants of pool equipment dominate the Utah and Idaho markets. Each builds the full equipment package — pumps, filters, heaters, automation, sanitization, lighting. Here’s the honest brand-by-brand comparison from a builder that installs all three.

Quick Verdict

• Pentair — premium, deep automation, strong dealer support. Best for premium builds.
• Hayward — strong mid-to-premium, broad availability, excellent automation. Most balanced choice.
• Jandy — solid mid-tier, especially good if your Jandy/Zodiac equipment is already installed.

Honestly, all three are excellent. The differences are nuance. The bigger choice is between equipment TIERS within a brand, not between brands.

Pumps

Pentair IntelliFlo (premium)

Industry-leading variable-speed pump. Quiet, energy-efficient, integrates beautifully with IntelliCenter automation. Higher price point. The benchmark.

Hayward TriStar VS / EcoStar

Strong mid-to-premium. Slightly less polished than IntelliFlo but solid performance. Good price-to-performance.

Jandy ePump

Solid choice especially within Jandy ecosystem. Reliable, less feature-rich than Pentair.

Filters

All three brands make excellent cartridge, DE, and sand filters. Differences are minor. We recommend cartridge filters for most Utah pools (less water waste than backwashing).

Heaters

Pentair MasterTemp (gas) / UltraTemp (heat pump)

MasterTemp is one of the most reliable gas heaters made. UltraTemp is a strong heat pump but has the same altitude limitations as all heat pumps.

Hayward Universal H-Series (gas) / HeatPro (heat pump)

H-Series is workhorse reliable. HeatPro heat pump is solid for lower-elevation Utah builds.

Raypak (used by all three brand ecosystems)

Many builders default to Raypak for pure heating performance regardless of pump/filter brand.

Automation

Pentair IntelliCenter

The premium automation system. Deep app, strong integrations, voice control via Alexa/Google. Best if you want top-tier control. Install: $2,500-$5,000.

Hayward OmniLogic

Excellent automation, similar features to IntelliCenter, slightly more affordable. Install: $2,200-$4,500.

Jandy iAquaLink

Mid-tier strong choice especially within Jandy equipment ecosystem. Install: $1,800-$3,800.

Salt Sanitization

• Pentair IntelliChlor — premium, integrates with IntelliCenter, expected 5-7 year cell life
• Hayward AquaRite — most popular installed system, broadly compatible, good price-performance
• Jandy AquaPure — solid choice, especially within Jandy automation ecosystem

Lighting

• Pentair IntelliBrite 5G — deepest color saturation, premium
• Hayward Universal ColorLogic — strong, broad fixture compatibility
• Jandy WaterColors — solid, especially within Jandy-equipped pool

Mixing Brands

Yes, you can mix brands across categories. But automation works best when most of your equipment is the same brand (the controller can monitor and adjust deeper). For new builds, we usually pick a primary brand and stick with it for everything.

Our Default Recommendation for Utah Pools

For new builds we typically install Pentair as a default — quality, automation depth, and dealer support all win for premium builds. For mid-tier and budget builds, Hayward is a strong choice with similar capability at slightly lower cost. Jandy works well as a third option, especially for Jandy-equipped retrofits.

Pool Equipment Install in Utah → · Pool Automation → · Free equipment quote →